Chapter 23, African American Popular Styles: One Long Ring Shout
In order to understand the continuity between traditional tribal music in Africa and the genres that were innovated in the US it is important to cite the most prominent aspect of group music making; the Ring Shout. For anyone who doesn't know what a Ring Shout is, it is the result of the banning of drums in the American south by slave owners and conservative religious groups. Nowhere was this more prominent than in New Orleans which was by every definition, an international community. In place of drums, the African American slaves would stand in a circle, shout and clap hands, at various intervals, individuals would enter the ring and contribute dance, a new shout or an additional rhythm. This is something that Henry Martin and Keith Waters discuss in the text Essential Jazz - The First 100 Years in which they write: "The shouters, formed in a ring, men and women alternating, their bodies close together, moved round and round on shuffling feet that never left the floor." (Martin/Waters p. 25) The video below is a modern recreation of the style of Ring Shout in which the eastern US slaves would be participating.
Original URL: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WrDJ0aIBu7k
Now, let us examine a video of traditional African drumming. This is a commercial for a music program but it contains many clips of well-researched music and its not hard to see the relationship it bares to the Ring Shout. Look how the emphasis is a combination between the individual dancers or performers and their accompanying community of musicians playing poly-rhythms.
Original URL: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kpe2Rk9I3bk
From there it is very easy to see how this general philosophy translated into the world of Jazz and Blues. In the Jazz tradition we can see the individual contribute in the practice of solo improvisation (such as in the video below)Jean Ferris, in the text Music, The Art of Listening notes that "Jazz developed from a combination of black and white music traditions, but was predominantly influenced by the rhythms and performance practices of [early] African Americans." (Ferris p. 307)
Original URL: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_55RJopDEIc
The Blues tradition is a little different however, we have to see Blues as essentially one long song that continues even after an individual interpretation is finished. Here we encounter our first real long-term contributions to a single work. Therefore; it isn't that blues song-writers weren't capable of writing other chord progressions, its just that they were lending their unique voice to a musical tradition.
Original URL: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yd60nI4sa9A
Original URL: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yRdDnrB5kM
You can hear that both examples above are a single chord progression even though they are two very different characters of pieces, thereby giving the individual artists an oppurtunity to contribute to the long Blues tradition.
So, how does the ring shout continue? Lets end with one of the most modern interpretations of individual contribution to a group style in the form of hip-hop club music. Often this type of rap is really just a set of lyrics that state “dance like this... now dance like that” but the emphasis is on the unique interpretation of the specific dance, as an example of this I give to you Soulja Boy's “Superman,” examine the cuts to individuals dancing to show off their own personality in the song. Universal Records doesn't allow embedding of video, so you have to go to YouTube to see this one:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LpocrqvP2Yg
Works Cited:
Martin, Henry. Essential Jazz - The First 100 Years. Thompson Schirmer. Belmount: 2005
Ferris, Jean. Music, The Art of Listening. McGraw-Hill. Boston: 1999
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

This was very interesting to read and watch, as I can now see the transition it made down to modern day jazz, etc. Nice work!
ReplyDeleteDid you ever find out why they banned drums, from religious circles and areas within the US? I've heard before that in African areas when drum rolls were playing, it was meant to summon up the "demons and spirits". But, I guess I dont' know the reasoning behind the ban. That may have been the reason for the banning within some religious circles. Just a thought. I'll have to research it some more!
What an interesting blog to read and I always learn so much from you! I had never heard of a ring shout or the relationship between that and West African Drumming and Dance. It is great how the modern hip hop and rap is a continuation of that with more variety but still a group event. I enjoyed watching each of the videos showing the progression and connection made in jazz. It would be fun to find out why they banned the drums as they are so essential to jazz music now. Great job!
ReplyDeleteHi Kathryn and Elissa,
ReplyDeleteThere are still some Charismatic and Conservative Christian groups that see the drum as a representation of Satan. This mostly stems from the colonization period of European empires into Africa and the greater middle east... Many Africans, Arabs and Indians used ceremonial drums in their native religious ceremonies. The Christian missionaries believed (for the most part, I'm kind of generalizing for space) that these native religions were planted by Satan to divert people from Christianity and that's how the association was made. ***Ironically, the old-testament Satan or "Ha-Satan" as he is known, is humanities' prosecutor and therefore work FOR God. The "Lucifer" character is a completely different person and most likely refers to the morning star of Venus.*** --- That's all besides the point, it is an example of ethno-centrism (or Euro-centrism) in white Americans believing that they were "civilizing" the African slaves and therefore, the practice of stripping them of their culture and freedom was a necessary step to making them more like us.
I do not mean to make it sound like Christianity is to blame for all of this - merely pointing out that Christianity was used to justify the action of forced acculturation.
Hey! As I was doing research for my blog, I came across a reason that drums were banned. The Africans used the drums not only to keep the rhythm for their music but also as a form of communication. The plantation owners feared that they would use the drums to summon one another for a revolt. In one case that did happen. However, the African-Americans were very resourceful and found other ways to pass messages along without the plantation owners knowing. I don’t think that the white Americans stripped the African slaves of their culture and freedom in order to make them more like us. I think they did that out of fear and because they wanted to feel a greater sense of superiority.
ReplyDeleteMichelle
ReplyDeleteSure, it's kind of one and the same, when I wrote that they wanted to make African slaves "more like us" I was being a bit caricature-ish, of course slave owners were not interested in "helping" the African people,or else they would have freed them, given them land, education, 40 acres and all that... but they needed a rationale for committing the acts they were doing. Religion and "saving the souls" of the soon to be slaves was a popular justification.
The truth is, if you look at colonial rule in Scandanavia (the Sami in paticular) India, Africa or the Middle east, you will see a banning of drums usually on the basis for religious grounds. Furthermore, if you look at the evangelical movement especially across Asia (take Benny Hinn, for instance)who state as a mission that they wish to stamp out "worship of idols and ancestors" it becomes clear that the banning of drums has traditionally been on religious grounds. I don't doubt that slave owners didn't want the slaves communicating on a mass scale but we have to look at historical trends as well.
OK, after reading my above posting, I figured I better cite some more sources, this is just a handful of websites that support what I am saying, please see them at your leisure.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.albatrus.org/english/church-order/worship/drums_suitable_worship_god.htm
- A discussion on the appropriateness of drums in church
http://www.christiandrummers.net/2007/02/14/drums-in-the-bible.htm
- More discussion on drums
http://www.utexas.edu/courses/sami/diehtu/giella/music/noaidi.htm
- An excellent article on the mistreatment of the Sami people by religious groups, see the section that says "Christian Response to the Sami Drum"
http://www.africasroots.com/AR_BOOK_PREVIEW_WEB.pdf - See p. 14 for the section on drums and native religious practices and how native religion was deemed "satanic."
http://www.webcitation.org/5kmoc6zLH
-Pat Robertson declares Hinduism "demonic"
http://mediamatters.org/research/200603200013
- Same stuff as above, different pastor